Shopping for art supplies for mixed media usually comes down to one decision: buy a dedicated surface first, or grab an all-in-one kit? After comparing ten popular options, the Strathmore 500 Series Heavyweight Mixed Media Pad stands out as the best overall pick because its 100% cotton rag paper handles wet layers, ink, and heavy collage better than anything else here. For tighter budgets, the Canson XL Mix Media Pad delivers surprising wet-media performance at a fraction of the price, while the KINGART Gel Stick set of 24 is the strongest pigment-only option for adding bold, blendable color. The main tradeoff across this category is paper weight and durability versus cost — cheap pads buckle under washes, and most bundled kits sacrifice paper quality for quantity. Keep reading for the full breakdown of which supplies fit your style, skill level, and budget.
Prime for Young Adults — start your free trial
Fast free delivery, streaming and member deals for eligible 18–24 year olds.
Try it freeAs an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Takeaways
- Paper weight was the single biggest differentiator: only the Strathmore 500 Series (cotton rag) and, to a lesser degree, the 98lb MOFUNY and SuFly pads resisted buckling under wet media — the Canson XL sits in the middle, while bundled kit papers fell short.
- All-in-one kits (Soucolor 192-pack, Colour Block 181-piece, Mixed Media Art Set with Easel) trade paper quality for variety, making them better as gift or starter sets than as serious mixed media foundations.
- Two near-identical 9×12 sketchbooks — MOFUNY and SuFly, both 98lb/160gsm with 60 sheets — split on price and binding, so the cheaper one wins unless availability says otherwise.
- Gel sticks like the KINGART set are the most versatile single-supply purchase here, working on paper, canvas, and even wood, but they demand a heavyweight surface to shine.
- The Prang Mixed Media Journal is the only true portable journal format in the lineup, making it the default pick for travel and outdoor sketching despite its smaller sheet count.
| KINGART Mixed Media Gel Stick Crayons, Set of 24 Colors |  | Best for Adding Wet-Dry Techniques | Number of Colors: 24 | Type: Water-soluble pigment gel crayons | Water Soluble: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Strathmore 500 Series Heavyweight Mixed Media Pad 6″ x 8″, 12 Sheets |  | Best Premium Paper | Paper Weight: 350 lb (570 g/m²) | Material: 100% cotton | Acid Free: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook 9×12, 60 Sheets, 98lb/160gsm |  | Best Value Sketchbook | Size: 9″ x 12″ | Sheets: 60 | Paper Weight: 98 lb / 160 gsm | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Canson XL Mix Media Pad 9×12, 60 Sheets |  | Best Overall Pick | Brand: Canson | Model Number: 100510927 | Sheet Size: 9″ x 12″ | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mixed Media Sketchbook 9″x12″, 30 Sheets |  | Best for Beginners and Young Artists | Size: 9″ x 12″ | Sheets: 30 | Paper Weight: 98 lb / 160 gsm | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Soucolor Art Supplies 192 Pack Deluxe Art Set |  | Best All-in-One Starter Arsenal | Total Pieces: 192 | Media Included: Crayons, colored pencils, oil pastels, watercolor, acrylic | Crayons: 60 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Colour Block 181-Piece Mixed Media Art Set in Wooden Case |  | Best for Exploring Advanced Techniques | Total Pieces: 181 | Media Included: Watercolor, acrylic, watercolor cakes, colored and watercolor pencils, oil and soft pastels, charcoal, graphite | Brushes: Natural hair and synthetic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SuFly Mixed Media Sketchbook 9×12, 60 Sheets |  | Best Heavyweight Paper Value | Size: 9 x 12 inches | Paper Weight: 98lb/160gsm | Sheets: 60 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mixed Media Art Set with Art Easel and Supplies Kit |  | Best Gift-Ready Kit with Easel | Total Pieces: 55 | Includes: Acrylic and watercolor paints, brushes, colored pencils, drawing accessories, wooden easel | Paper: Watercolor notebook, sketch notebook, drawing board | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Prang Mixed Media Journal |  | Best Budget Journal for Kids and Classrooms | Size: 8.5 x 11 inches | Binding: Spiral bound | Backing: Heavy chipboard | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| art supplies for mixed media | Binding | Paper Weight | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| KINGART Mixed Media Gel Stick | — | — | — |
| Strathmore 500 Series Heavywei | Glue bound | 350 lb (570 g/m²) | 6" x 8" |
| MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook | Ring bound, 360-degree rotation | 98 lb / 160 gsm | 9" x 12" |
| Canson XL Mix Media Pad 9×12 | Pad with perforated pages | 98 lb / 160 g | — |
| Mixed Media Sketchbook 9"x12" | Spiral-bound, lays flat | 98 lb / 160 gsm | 9" x 12" |
| Soucolor Art Supplies 192 Pack | — | — | — |
| Colour Block 181-Piece Mixed M | — | — | — |
| SuFly Mixed Media Sketchbook 9 | Side spiral | 98lb/160gsm | 9 x 12 inches |
| Mixed Media Art Set with Art E | — | — | — |
| Prang Mixed Media Journal | Spiral bound | — | 8.5 x 11 inches |
More Details on Our Top Picks
KINGART Mixed Media Gel Stick Crayons, Set of 24 Colors
Most of the items in this roundup are surfaces to work on — this is the tool that changes how you work. These water-soluble gel crayons go down dry like a lipstick-soft crayon, then dissolve into watercolor washes with a brush, making them a genuine mixed media instrument rather than a single-technique supply. They also perform on fabric and wood, which paper pads like the Canson XL Mix Media Pad obviously can’t address. The tradeoff is control: blending requires water, so spontaneous precision work takes practice, and the snap-on caps can loosen in a bag. Compared with buying paints and brushes separately, this set keeps things portable and low-mess, which suits journaling and travel. Serious painters will find the pigment load lighter than professional-grade watercolor, but for layering over sketches on any of the sketchbooks here, they hold their own.
Pros:- Water-soluble formula enables both dry and watercolor techniques
- Works on paper, fabric, and wood, not just sketchbook surfaces
- Compact sturdy case travels well
- 24 vibrant colors cover most mixed media layering needs
Cons:- Blending depends on water, limiting spontaneous detail work
- Pigment load falls short of professional-grade media
- Round snap-on caps can pop off in transit
Best for: Journal artists and travelers who want paint-like effects without hauling brushes and water cups
Not ideal for: Professional watercolorists who need archival pigment density and precise control
- Number of Colors:24
- Type:Water-soluble pigment gel crayons
- Water Soluble:Yes
- Design:Round, ambidextrous, snap-on cap
- Compatible Surfaces:Paper, fabric, wood, and more
- Portability:Sturdy storage case included
Our verdict“Pick these if you want one versatile tool that bridges drawing and painting across surfaces; skip them if you need archival, professional watercolor results.”
Strathmore 500 Series Heavyweight Mixed Media Pad 6″ x 8″, 12 Sheets
This is the paper that lets you throw everything at it. At 350 lb (570 g/m²) and 100% cotton, it behaves like a watercolor board: heavy washes, acrylic layers, collage glue, and scraping all stay flat without buckling. Compare that to the MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook at 98 lb — fine for sketches and light washes, but it will cockle under a real wet-on-wet session. The Strathmore costs far more per sheet, and that’s the honest tradeoff: 12 sheets go fast when you’re experimenting. The 6″ x 8″ format doubles as both limitation and feature — it forces small studies, keeps costs per piece reasonable, and suits art journaling. If your mixed media work leans toward heavy, wet, layered techniques and you want it to last, this is the surface to beat; for dry-media sketching it’s overkill.
Pros:- 350 lb cotton paper handles saturated washes without buckling
- 100% cotton and acid-free for archival longevity
- Accepts watercolor, gouache, acrylic, and drawing media on one surface
- Small format suits studies and journal pages
Cons:- Only 12 sheets per pad at a premium price
- 6″ x 8″ size is impractical for larger compositions
Best for: Artists doing heavy wet layering, collage, or archival pieces who need paper that won’t buckle
Not ideal for: Budget-conscious students or anyone needing lots of sheets for practice studies
- Paper Weight:350 lb (570 g/m²)
- Material:100% cotton
- Acid Free:Yes
- Size:6″ x 8″
- Sheets:12
- Binding:Glue bound
- Compatible Media:Watercolor, gouache, acrylic, drawing media
Our verdict“Worth the price only if your techniques are too aggressive for standard 98 lb pads — otherwise the Canson XL covers the basics for less.”
MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook 9×12, 60 Sheets, 98lb/160gsm
When the priority is volume of paper for the price, this pad delivers: 60 sheets at 9″ x 12″ with a durable cover and a ring binding that rotates a full 360 degrees — handy for working at odd angles or tearing a page around. Against the similarly sized Canson XL Mix Media Pad, the paper weight is identical at 98 lb, so the real differences are the binding style and the recyclable paper claim. Where it falls short of the Strathmore 500 Series is durability under stress: this is light-to-medium duty paper, and heavy gesso, thick acrylic impasto, or aggressive wet blending will overwhelm it. For daily sketching, ink, charcoal, and occasional light watercolor, it holds up well and the cover protects finished pages in a backpack better than a bare glue-bound pad. It’s the workhorse choice, not the specialty one.
Pros:- 60 sheets offer strong cost per page at full 9×12 size
- Ring binding rotates 360 degrees for flexible working angles
- Durable cover protects artwork in transit
- Handles pencil, ink, charcoal, and light watercolor
Cons:- 98 lb weight can’t handle heavy or textured media
- Ring binding is less tidy for presentation than glue-bound or perforated pads
Best for: Students and daily sketchers who burn through paper and want quantity without wrecking their budget
Not ideal for: Artists building wet, heavy, or textured layers — 98 lb paper will buckle and pill
- Size:9″ x 12″
- Sheets:60
- Paper Weight:98 lb / 160 gsm
- Binding:Ring bound, 360-degree rotation
- Material:Recyclable mixed media paper
- Best Media:Pencil, ink, charcoal, light watercolor
Our verdict“The best sheet-count-per-dollar option here for everyday mixed media sketching, as long as your techniques stay light on water.”
Canson XL Mix Media Pad 9×12, 60 Sheets
This pad earns the top spot because it solves the most common mixed media problem: wanting to try wet and dry media on the same page without switching pads. The 98 lb heavyweight paper takes watercolor and gouache acceptably while staying friendly to markers, pencil, and pen, and the perforated pages detach cleanly — a genuine advantage over the MOFUNY sketchbook, whose ring-bound pages are better for keeping a running book than for presenting or gifting finished work. It can’t compete with the Strathmore 500 Series for saturation-heavy pieces — expect some buckling on very wet washes — but it costs a fraction as much per sheet while offering the same useful 9″ x 12″ format. For most artists balancing versatility, price, and availability, this is the default choice that other picks here are variations on. Pair it with the KINGART gel crayons and you have a complete starter setup.
Pros:- Handles watercolor, gouache, acrylic, markers, and dry media competently
- Perforated pages remove cleanly for framing or sharing
- 60 sheets at 9×12 for a competitive price
- Widely available and consistent quality
Cons:- Very wet techniques cause noticeable buckling
- No warranty included
Best for: All-around artists who want one reliable pad for watercolor, gouache, markers, and drawing
Not ideal for: Artists whose work is dominated by saturated wet-on-wet watercolor — the 98 lb paper will warp
- Brand:Canson
- Model Number:100510927
- Sheet Size:9″ x 12″
- Number of Sheets:60
- Paper Weight:98 lb / 160 g
- Binding:Pad with perforated pages
- Recommended Uses:Acrylic, drawing, painting, pen and pencil, watercolor
- Item Weight:1.9 pounds
Our verdict“The safest all-purpose buy in this lineup — versatile, affordable, and clean-removing — unless heavy watercolor is your main medium.”
Mixed Media Sketchbook 9″x12″, 30 Sheets
What separates this pad from the otherwise similar Canson XL and MOFUNY options isn’t the 98 lb paper — it’s the beginner-friendly package: micro-perforated pages for clean removal, a spiral binding that lays flat on a desk, and acid-free, bleed-resistant paper that forgives ink and marker mistakes that would soak through cheaper sketchbooks. Half the sheet count of its 60-sheet rivals is the honest cost, but that’s actually reasonable for a young artist or hobbyist who experiments slowly rather than sketching daily. The paper still shares the standard limitation of this weight class: sustained heavy watercolor will test it, so ambitious wet pieces belong on the Strathmore 500 Series instead. As an entry point or a gift — the maker positions it exactly that way — it removes friction: pages tear out for the fridge door, and the book behaves itself on a table.
Pros:- Bleed-resistant, acid-free paper handles ink and markers well
- Micro-perforated pages detach cleanly for display or gifting
- Spiral binding lays flat for comfortable desk work
- Low-commitment sheet count suits experimenting beginners
Cons:- Only 30 sheets — the fewest in this lineup for the size
- Heavy watercolor applications risk bleed-through and warping
- Spiral binding can bend or loosen with rough handling
Best for: Kids, teens, and casual hobbyists who want an easy, forgiving sketchbook for sharing their work
Not ideal for: Productive artists who need more than 30 sheets or want paper that survives heavy wet media
- Size:9″ x 12″
- Sheets:30
- Paper Weight:98 lb / 160 gsm
- Binding:Spiral-bound, lays flat
- Perforation:Micro-perforated
- Material:Acid-free, fade-resistant, bleed-resistant paper
- Compatible Media:Watercolor (light), acrylic, pastel, ink
Our verdict“A smart low-stakes gift or first sketchbook for young artists, provided expectations stay at the marker-and-light-wash level.”
Soucolor Art Supplies 192 Pack Deluxe Art Set
Soucolor’s 192-piece set is the most complete bundled kit in this roundup, pairing six different media families with artist-grade paper pads for each. Compared with the Colour Block 181-Piece set below, it leans more heavily on quantity — 60 crayons alone — while offering fewer specialist tools like charcoal sticks or a wooden manikin. The dual-drawer wooden case keeps everything sorted, though reaching supplies in the bottom drawer mid-project is genuinely awkward. This pick makes the most sense for someone who wants to sample every medium at once rather than build depth in one. The included color wheel and three canvas boards push it toward true mixed-media experimentation, not just drawing.
Pros:- Covers crayon, pencil, pastel, watercolor, and acrylic in a single purchase
- Includes matching pads and canvas boards so every medium has proper paper
- Wooden case keeps 192 pieces organized and transportable
- Built-in color wheel helps beginners learn mixing
Cons:- Dual-drawer design makes frequently used supplies hard to grab quickly
- Individual piece quality is mid-tier — serious artists will outgrow the pigments fast
Best for: Beginners and families who want every major medium in one gift-ready box without shopping piecemeal
Not ideal for: Artists who already own paper and brushes — most of the value here is redundancy, and the pigment quality won’t satisfy experienced painters
- Total Pieces:192
- Media Included:Crayons, colored pencils, oil pastels, watercolor, acrylic
- Crayons:60
- Colored Pencils:24
- Paint Brushes:8
- Canvas Boards:3 (A4)
- Paper:Sketch pad, watercolor paper, acrylic pad
- Case:Portable wooden case with dual drawers
Our verdict“Buy this if you’re starting from zero and want one box that unlocks every medium; skip it if you already own a sketchbook like the SuFly 9×12 and decent brushes.”
Colour Block 181-Piece Mixed Media Art Set in Wooden Case
Where the Soucolor set wins on raw count, Colour Block wins on sophistication. Instead of padding with 60 crayons, it spends its 181 pieces on watercolor pencils, charcoal, graphite sticks, soft pastels, and blending stumps — the tools that actually define mixed-media layering. The included wooden manikin and color theory guide signal that this kit is aimed at skill-building, not just quantity. Tradeoffs are real: there’s less paper included than Soucolor provides, and no tutorials, so you’ll need outside resources to learn techniques like combining ink with pastel. The sturdy case travels well, making it a step up from the Soucolor’s bulkier drawers for artists who work away from home.
Pros:- Includes specialist tools like charcoal sticks, blending stumps, and watercolor pencils
- Wooden manikin and color theory guide support actual skill development
- Mix of natural hair and synthetic brushes suits both watercolor and acrylic
- Compact wooden case is easier to travel with than larger kits
Cons:- Less paper included than competing kits — expect to add a pad like the Canson XL Mix Media
- No instructions or tutorials, so self-directed learning is required
Best for: Intermediate hobbyists who want to layer wet and dry media and learn technique-focused tools like charcoal and watercolor pencils
Not ideal for: Absolute beginners who want guidance — there are no instructions, and the tool variety assumes you already know what a kneaded eraser or sanding block is for
- Total Pieces:181
- Media Included:Watercolor, acrylic, watercolor cakes, colored and watercolor pencils, oil and soft pastels, charcoal, graphite
- Brushes:Natural hair and synthetic
- Tools:Kneaded eraser, blending stumps, sanding block, sharpener, color wheel
- Extras:Wooden manikin, color theory guide, watercolor pad
- Case:Wooden storage case
Our verdict“This is the kit for artists ready to move past basics into genuine mixed-media techniques, while Soucolor remains the better pick for pure beginners.”
SuFly Mixed Media Sketchbook 9×12, 60 Sheets
SuFly’s 9×12 sketchbook competes directly with the MOFUNY 9×12 pad, and the differentiator is sheet count plus hard covers: 60 sheets of 98lb paper in a protective rigid shell that survives being tossed in a backpack. The weight handles light watercolor washes, gouache, marker, and acrylic layers without the buckling you’d get from a standard drawing pad like the Prang journal. Perforated edges mean finished pieces tear out cleanly for framing or gifting. The tradeoff is the spiral binding — it’s great for lying flat but awkward for scanning, and 60 sheets disappear fast if you’re painting daily. Compared with the smaller Strathmore 500 Series pad, this is the volume pick with slightly less premium paper.
Pros:- 98lb/160gsm weight supports pencil through light acrylic and gouache
- Perforated sheets remove cleanly for display
- Hard covers double as a drawing surface away from a desk
- 60 sheets offer strong per-page value at this size
Cons:- Spiral binding adds bulk and makes the book less pocketable
- Not heavy enough for repeated wet layers without warping
Best for: Students and daily-practice artists who burn through paper and need one book that tolerates both sketching and wet media
Not ideal for: Artists doing heavy, saturated watercolor work — 98lb handles washes but will still warp where 140lb+ paper won’t
- Size:9 x 12 inches
- Paper Weight:98lb/160gsm
- Sheets:60
- Binding:Side spiral
- Cover:Hard cover
- Perforated Pages:Yes
- Compatible Media:Pencil, ink, marker, pastel, gouache, light acrylic and watercolor
Our verdict“The best all-purpose workhorse pad here — buy it for volume and versatility, and step up to Strathmore 500 Series only if you need archival-grade wet-media performance.”
Mixed Media Art Set with Art Easel and Supplies Kit
This 55-piece set takes a different approach from the Soucolor and Colour Block giants: instead of maximum supplies, it bundles a wooden easel with built-in storage, so the buyer gets a complete workspace, not just materials. That makes it the strongest gift candidate in the roundup — it arrives looking like a real studio setup. The tradeoff is depth. With only 55 pieces, painters get fewer colors than the 192-piece Soucolor offers, and there’s little brand transparency on pigment quality. Still, the included drawing board and two notebooks mean someone can start painting within minutes of unboxing. Compared with buying a kit and easel separately, the integration and price logic here are hard to beat for a first setup.
Pros:- Wooden easel with storage trays creates a ready-to-use workspace
- Includes both watercolor and sketch notebooks plus a drawing board
- Lightweight and compact enough for art classes and travel
- Everything arrives organized, making it genuinely gift-ready
Cons:- Only 55 pieces means a narrower color range than larger kits
- Limited brand information makes pigment quality a gamble
Best for: Gift-givers and beginners who want a complete painting station — easel, paints, brushes, and paper — in one box
Not ideal for: Experienced artists who already own an easel and brushes; the paint selection is limited and the brand doesn’t publish quality certifications
- Total Pieces:55
- Includes:Acrylic and watercolor paints, brushes, colored pencils, drawing accessories, wooden easel
- Paper:Watercolor notebook, sketch notebook, drawing board
- Materials:Wood, high-quality pigments
- Portability:Lightweight with internal storage trays
- Skill Level:Beginners through advanced, students, kids
Our verdict“The smart choice when the goal is a complete first studio or a impressive gift, rather than the deepest supply collection.”
Prang Mixed Media Journal
Prang’s journal is the lightweight option here, and that’s its whole point. At 8.5 x 11 inches — standard notebook size — with a chipboard back for drawing support, it’s built for classroom shelves, kids’ backpacks, and bulk purchases where price per book matters. It can’t compete with the SuFly 9×12 on wet-media performance; heavier washes will buckle this paper. But for sketching, drawing, and light painting, plus the acid-free guarantee that keeps work from yellowing, it does the job at a fraction of the cost. The Prang Promise replacement policy is a genuine plus for teachers ordering in quantity. Think of it as the everyday journal you don’t mind filling with experiments, saving your SuFly or Strathmore for finished pieces.
Pros:- Standard notebook size fits easily into backpacks and folders
- Chipboard backing provides solid support for lap or desk drawing
- Acid-free paper resists yellowing over time
- Prang Promise guarantees replacement of defective products
Cons:- Lighter paper weight limits wet-media and heavy layering
- No sheet count or weight specs published, making comparison shopping harder
Best for: Teachers, parents, and students who need inexpensive journals for daily sketching and light media in classroom quantities
Not ideal for: Mixed-media artists working with wet layers — this paper is thinner than the 98lb SuFly and won’t hold up to acrylic or heavy watercolor
- Size:8.5 x 11 inches
- Binding:Spiral bound
- Backing:Heavy chipboard
- Paper:Acid-free, recyclable
- Best Uses:Sketching, drawing, light painting
- Brand Guarantee:Prang Promise replacement policy
- Manufacturer:Prang (Dixon Ticonderoga family)
Our verdict“The value pick for sketch-first users and classrooms — just don’t expect it to survive the wet techniques the SuFly sketchbook shrugs off.”
How We Picked
My ranking logic starts with the thing mixed media punishes hardest: the surface. Every option was evaluated on paper weight and fiber content, because a pad that buckles under a light watercolor wash or tears when collage glue is applied fails the core purpose regardless of how many sheets it includes. I weighted wet-media durability, dry-media tooth, and page count per dollar heavily, then judged pigment products on opacity, blendability, and surface versatility.
The second tier of criteria separated the kits from the pads. For bundled sets, I looked at whether the included paper could actually support the included supplies, the quality ceiling of the pigments, and whether the packaging adds real value or just cost. Finally, I factored in buyer fit: a beginner needs breadth and forgiveness, an experienced mixed media artist needs one excellent surface, and a gift buyer needs presentation. That is why a single cotton pad outranks a 192-piece kit — depth beats breadth for this specific craft.
| art supplies for mixed media | Binding |
|---|---|
| KINGART Mixed Media Gel Stick | — |
| Strathmore 500 Series Heavywei | Glue bound |
| MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook | Ring bound, 360-degree rotation |
| Canson XL Mix Media Pad 9×12 | Pad with perforated pages |
| Mixed Media Sketchbook 9"x12" | Spiral-bound, lays flat |
| Soucolor Art Supplies 192 Pack | — |
| Colour Block 181-Piece Mixed M | — |
| SuFly Mixed Media Sketchbook 9 | Side spiral |
| Mixed Media Art Set with Art E | — |
| Prang Mixed Media Journal | Spiral bound |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Art Supplies For Mixed Media
Mixed media is uniquely punishing on supplies because every layer you add — gesso, ink, acrylic, collage, marker — stresses the surface and the pigments beneath it. Before buying anything on this list, here are the factors that actually determine whether your supplies survive the process.Paper Weight and Fiber Content
Weight is advertised in pounds or gsm, and the numbers matter more than most beginners expect. Anything under 90lb/190gsm will warp with even a light wash, forcing you to tape pages down or accept buckling. 98lb/160gsm pads like the MOFUNY and SuFly are the practical floor for wet work, while true freedom — heavy gesso, acrylic layers, wet collage — starts at 140lb and gets comfortable at the cotton-rag level of the Strathmore 500 Series. Fiber content is the hidden variable: cotton rag absorbs water evenly and lies flat, whereas wood-pulp paper absorbs unevenly and pills under scrubbing. The common mistake is buying a thick pad of cheap paper instead of a thin pad of good paper — sheet count is the worst value metric in this category.
Buy the Surface Before the Supplies
The most frequent buying error in mixed media is the reverse: purchasing a large kit of paints, pastels, and markers first, then discovering the included paper can’t handle any of them. Almost every bundled set in this comparison includes paper that is fine for dry sketching but fails under wet media. A better starting strategy is one quality pad plus two or three versatile pigments, then expanding as technique demands. This also avoids the trap of duplicate supplies — many kits ship with oil pastels, gel sticks, and watercolor cakes that overlap heavily in function.
Sizing and Format: Pad, Journal, or Kit
Format changes how you work more than most buyers realize. A spiral-bound 9×12 pad lies flat and tears out cleanly for framing or scanning, which suits studio practice and finished pieces. A bound journal like the Prang keeps everything sequential, which builds skill through repetition but makes single-sheet removal messy. Small formats like the 6×8 Strathmore force tighter compositions and are genuinely better for daily practice, travel, and technique experiments where you want low stakes per page. Match the format to your actual habit: if you sketch at a desk weekly, a journal wins; if you produce finished work, a pad wins.
Kit Value Versus Kit Quality
Piece counts are the marketing lever in this category, and they are misleading. A 192-piece set sounds like a studio in a box, but the per-item cost is often under a dollar, which tells you what the pigments are like: chalky pastels, weak watercolors, and brushes that shed. Kits do three things well — gifting, sampling mediums you have never tried, and supplying casual household or classroom use. If you already know you love one medium, skip kits entirely and put the budget into that medium’s mid-tier tools. The wooden-case Colour Block set is the exception worth noting: the case itself carries real utility and resale appeal.
Acid-Free and Archival Claims
Nearly every product here claims to be acid-free, and the claim mostly matters for work you want to keep. Acid-free paper resists yellowing for decades, while cheaper paper can shift color within a few years — invisible now, disappointing later. If you sell work, gift pieces, or keep a portfolio, archival certification is non-negotiable and the Strathmore 500 justifies its price partly on this basis. For practice pages, technique studies, and kids’ projects, the claim is nice but not worth paying extra for. The mistake to avoid is mixing non-archival collage materials into archival paper — the weakest component determines the lifespan of the whole piece.
When to Pay More
Pay more when wet media is central to your practice, because paper failure destroys hours of layered work — this is the clearest quality cliff in the category. Pay more for cotton rag when you sell or frame work, since texture and longevity both improve. Do not pay more for sheet count, decorative packaging, or pigment variety you will not use within a year, because dry watercolor cakes and pastels degrade and gel sticks pick up debris. A reasonable progression looks like this: start with a Canson XL or 98lb pad to learn, upgrade to the Strathmore 500 once you commit layers to a page, and add specialty pigments one at a time as specific techniques call for them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use the paper that comes in art kits for wet mixed media techniques?
Usually not, and this is the biggest letdown in kit purchases. The paper bundled in sets like the Soucolor and Colour Block collections is typically lightweight wood-pulp stock designed for dry media — pencil, marker, and light pastel work. A watercolor wash will buckle it, and acrylic or collage glue will cause pilling, curling, or tearing. If you buy a kit, treat the paper as practice stock for dry sketching and pair it with a dedicated mixed media pad for anything involving water, gesso, or glue. That combination actually works well: the kit supplies the pigments, and a quality pad supplies the surface those pigments deserve.
Is the Strathmore 500 Series really worth the premium over the Canson XL?
It depends entirely on how wet your work gets. The Strathmore 500 uses cotton rag fiber, which stays flat under heavy washes, tolerates scrubbing and layer removal, and has archival longevity — meaningful advantages if you build pieces over multiple sessions or want to frame the result. The Canson XL handles light washes serviceably and is roughly a quarter of the price, but it will buckle with saturated techniques and is not archival. My honest framing: the Canson XL is the better value per sheet for practice and learning, while the Strathmore 500 is the better value per finished piece. Many artists keep both and match the paper to the stakes of the page.
What’s the difference between the MOFUNY and SuFly 9×12 sketchbooks — they look identical?
They are nearly the same product: both are 9×12 pads with 60 sheets of 98lb/160gsm paper, which puts them in the same performance tier — solid for dry media, acceptable for light wet media, and not suited to heavy collage or acrylic layers. The practical differences come down to price at the time of purchase, binding quality, and availability, all of which fluctuate between the two listings. Whichever is cheaper on the day you buy is the correct choice, since the paper performance is functionally indistinguishable. If you notice one listing a spiral binding and the other a tape binding, favor the spiral for flat working and easy page removal.
Do I need gel sticks if I already have watercolors and acrylics?
Gel sticks earn their place through immediacy and surface versatility rather than replacing either medium. They apply like a wax crayon but blend with a wet brush into watercolor-like washes, and they grip surfaces where acrylic feels heavy — including dark papers, wood, and canvas board. For mixed media specifically, they excel at quick color blocking, layering over textured collage, and travel work since they need no water cup to make marks. The KINGART 24-color set covers a workable palette without duplicating what your existing paints do. If your work is strictly traditional watercolor on paper, skip them; if you experiment across surfaces, they are one of the cheapest ways to expand your range.
Which option is best for a complete beginner who doesn’t know which mediums they’ll like?
A kit is genuinely the right call in that specific situation, despite my reservations about kit paper quality. The Colour Block 181-piece set is the strongest choice here because the wooden case organizes the supplies and the range is broad enough to sample drawing, watercolor, acrylic, and pastel techniques for months. Pair it with an inexpensive 98lb pad like the MOFUNY or Canson XL so your wet-media experiments happen on paper that can take them. Expect to replace whichever pigments you fall in love with within a few months — kits are for discovery, not mastery. Once you know your medium, sell or gift the remainder and invest in mid-tier tools for that one discipline.
Conclusion
Matching these ten options to buyer types makes the decision straightforward. For the best overall pick, the Strathmore 500 Series Heavyweight Mixed Media Pad earns the top spot because surface quality is the foundation of every mixed media technique, and cotton rag paper simply outperforms everything else here. The Canson XL Mix Media Pad is the best value — it delivers most of the practical wet-media capability at a fraction of the Strathmore’s price. On the premium side, the Colour Block 181-Piece Wooden Case Set is the standout gift or presentation purchase, with the caveat that its bundled paper is practice-grade. For beginners, the combination of the Soucolor 192-pack or Colour Block kit plus an inexpensive 98lb pad offers breadth for discovery without wasting good paper on experiments. Specific needs round out the list: the MOFUNY and SuFly 60-sheet pads are the workhorse choices for volume sketching, the Prang Mixed Media Journal wins for travel and daily practice, the KINGART Gel Sticks are the best single pigment purchase for surface versatility, and the Strathmore 6×8 size is ideal for small-format studies. Buy the surface that matches your wettest technique first, add pigments second, and you will not go wrong with any of these picks.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
